Vulnerability Scanning Policy
Vulnerability scanning is an important and necessary component of any computer security plan as it provides
feedback on the eﬀectiveness of security procedures and can alert system administrators to potentially serious
problems. However vulnerability scanning also has the potential to reveal protected information and is
frequently used as part of an attempt to compromise system security. The following policy details the
conditions under which vulnerability scans may be performed on the CSM network.
Vulnerability scanning is a process by which devices connected to the network are probed in an attempt
to identify security related issues including, but not limited to; missing or weak passwords, insecure soft-
ware installations, software with known security issues, and back-door administration programs installed on
already compromised hosts.
Any equipment attached to the Colorado School of Mines’ network is subject to security vulnerability
scanning performed by the department of Academic Computing and Networking’s security team. The fol-
lowing policy describes the conditions under which this scanning takes place as well as the responsibilities
of the AC&N staﬀ involved in scanning.
Hosts found to contain security weaknesses will be dealt with in accordance with standing AC&N policies
(see the document Network Users Rights and Responsibilities.)
1. Domain-level scan: A periodic scan of all equipment attached to the CSM network targeted at known
2. Incident-response scan: An emergency scan initiated as a result of a speciﬁc security related incident.
3. Prohibited-service scan: A scan for a speciﬁc prohibited service, as deﬁned in the department of
Academic Computing and Networking’s policy for network use1.
4. Responsible User: The person ultimately responsible for the equipment in question. In most cases
the user of the system, however in the case of students who are assigned equipment owned by the
school, the user responsible for the system is the faculty member responsible for the equipment not the
5. Responsible Admin: The person (or persons) with administrative authority over the equipment. This
includes anyone who performs routine maintenance on the equipment.
6. Incident response team: Those persons who are involved in responding to a speciﬁc security related
incident. Only the department of Academic Computing and Networking may establish an incident
response team, which is typically headed up by a member of AC&N’s security team, and may also
include faculty and students with a vested interested in the incident under investigation.
Policies and procedures
• Policies for domain-level scans:
– Domain-level scans may only be performed by the department of Academic Computing and Net-
working’s security team.
– AC&N will notify the campus at least 24 hours prior to any domain-level scan.
1As of 1-Oct-02, the only service prohibited on campus is open mail relays.
– Domain-level scans are performed on an opt-out basis. That is, owners of network attached
equipment who do not want their equipment scanned must notify Computing and Networking
of the desire to opt-out of the scan. Only the user responsible for a host may opt-out of the
scanning process. AC&N will make a web-page or similar technology available allowing users to
easily communicate their desire to opt-out.
– Security issues found during domain-level scans will be communicated to AC&N’s department
level support staﬀ as well as the responsible user and admin. Statistical reductions of the results
of a scan may be made available to a wider audience.
• Policies for incident response scans:
– Incident-response scans may only be performed by the department of AC&N’s incident response
– Incident response scans may be initiated during the investigation of a security incident without
prior notiﬁcation and without regard to the opt-out list.
– Incident response scans may only be done in response to an active security related incident and
will be limited to that equipment AC&N believes is threatened by or implicated in the incident
– Results of incident response scans will only be disclosed to members of the incident response team,
and the responsible user and admin. Statistical reductions of the results of a scan may be made
available to a wider audience.
• Prohibited Service Scans:
– Prohibited service scans may only be performed by the department of AC&N’s security team.
– AC&N will notify the campus at least 24 hours prior to any prohibited-services scan.
– Users may not opt-out of prohibited-service scans.
– Prohibited services found during prohibited-service scans will be communicated to AC&N’s de-
partment level support staﬀ as well as the responsible user and admin. Statistical reductions of
the results of a scan may be made available to a wider audience. The identiﬁed prohibited service
will be dealt with in accordance with the policy for that service.
• Other scans:
– Administrators and users responsible for equipment may (and in fact are encouraged to) scan the
equipment for which they are directly responsible. Note that employees who report to AC&N
have additional policies regarding scanning.
– No one outside Academic Computing and Networking’s security team is authorized to perform
scans of equipment they are not directly responsible for. Such scans are considered a violation of
school policy and may result in disciplinary action.